Most neighborhoods would jump at the chance for a road repair project, but for residents of the Orchard Circle neighborhood, the subject is more nuanced.
Located off Concord Avenue, the neighborhood that includes Orchard Street and Stone Road is marked by a circular green space. It’s not a rotary, though it’s often mistaken for one — even popular navigation apps interpret it as such — and traffic travels in both directions.
In February of this year, residents received a paving notice — one that was well-received until details from the project began to emerge.
In addition to paving the roads, which are marked by potholes and other signs of wear and tear, town staff are also looking at creating T-intersections in the two locations where Orchard Street meets Orchard Circle, and a third where Orchard Circle meets Stone Road. It also involves building new sidewalks on Orchard Street, connecting Concord Avenue with School Street.
“I think people are a bit shocked they can just come in, without consulting anybody,” said Mark Carthy, a 32-year resident of the neighborhood.
Town officials for the project did not respond to requests for comment.
“We are in support of the paving,” Carthy emphasized. “The question was the other items that were being added to the paving that we only heard well after the plan had been put together.”
About 30 neighbors signed a petition asking the town to put a pause on its plans and to consider the input of residents.
“It’s just money being spent on something we don’t need,” he said.
At a recent Select Board meeting, Town Engineer Wayne Chouinard explained that the project, which was originally part of the fiscal year 2024 Pavement Management Program, got pushed to FY25 and then to FY26. He said projects are not picked randomly but through a selection process that involves a survey completed every five years to assess road conditions.
Budgeted at about $400,000, Chouinard said these are the last three streets set for repaving this year. The town has already completed 15 others.
“When we are doing these, we could simply go in there and pave them, but that doesn’t accomplish everything,” he said.
Safe roads and walkable sidewalks are concerns frequently raised by people in town, and this project aims to address both, Assistant Town Engineer Ahmet Caus said. An otherwise quiet spot, the neighborhood is a highly trafficked route during peak hours, specifically when students are walking or cycling to Belmont Middle and High School. It’s also a popular location for parents to drop off their students before getting caught in the commuter traffic.
“Instead of large sweeping curves … we’re trying to slow down the traffic,” Chouinard said.
The plans also create more space for pedestrians.
But residents of the neighborhood question the approach. They say the new intersections would narrow the roads, potentially making them more difficult to navigate, and the “bump out” would add to the front of people’s homes, leaving homeowners responsible for seasonal maintenance.
“I don’t think there are bad intentions,” Carthy told The Voice on a recent walk through the neighborhood. “I think it’s [missing] a process of including neighbors.”
Corinne McCue Olmsted, a 10-year resident of the neighborhood, said speeding is not an issue where the roads meet the circle, or in the circle itself. It’s an issue when cars descend Stone Road, a one-way street, from School Street, she said. For that reason, residents are asking instead for a speed bump at the upper end of Stone Road to mitigate speeding concerns.

“My question has continued to be: What problem are you trying to solve?” McCue asked town officials last week. “Does this overdone infrastructure solve it?”
Rob Cosinuke, whose property sits at the proposed T-intersection at Orchard Circle and Stone Road, said the plan seems to be “overkill” and questioned its overall impact on the neighborhood.
“I understand the town wants traffic to come to a stop as drivers enter the circle from Stone Road, but why does it need to be at a right angle?” he wrote in an email to The Voice. “If it was at a lesser angle, traffic would still stop and the bump out could be smaller.”
Ultimately, Carthy said he hopes for more engagement with the neighbors.
“The people know the street,” he said. “They know what’s needed.”
