Belmont High School offers over 20 Advanced Placement (AP) exams each year, aligning with the courses offered for students. In the past, some students have opted to take additional exams that rely on self-study outside of the classroom.
This year, however, the school will no longer offer self-study AP exams due to constraints on space, according to Superintendent Jill Geiser. The school offered eight additional exams last year, outside of ones tied to courses.
“This issue is about the logistics of administering additional tests for students who self-study. Namely, space is an ongoing concern,” Geiser said during the Oct. 27 School Committee meeting. “Tests are tied to specific dates at Belmont High School, and they are struggling to find locations for all the tests that are happening during the school day.”
Geiser and BHS Principal Isaac Taylor did not respond to further requests for comment.
The decision to stop offering the tests originally came last year, school officials said.
“My understanding is that it was widely shared across the school last year, so I will work with [Taylor] to broaden that communication,” Assistant Superintendent Lucia Sullivan told the School Committee.
A petition started by Belmont parents and students has gathered 174 signatures asking the school to reconsider its decision, explore “practical alternatives” to make the test administration sustainable for the future, and request earlier notice of policy changes surrounding exams.
“Our intention is to approach this matter constructively and in partnership with the school. We are not seeking to overlook the practical constraints involved in administering AP exams. Rather, we hope to work together to find a reasonable solution that supports the school’s operational needs while preserving opportunities for students who are motivated to pursue advanced learning in physics and other STEM fields,” the petition states.
Student representative Ganza Masozera told the School Committee that many students feel as if they got “the rug pulled out from under them.”
“I think one of the big things is communication about it, because it feels like people didn’t know,” Masozera said in an interview. “All the spots in other schools are filled up, and so it was bad for everyone — for the students and for the parents — because it felt like they were just like locked out in every way.”
Nearly 1,900 individual AP tests were administered at BHS last year. Of those tests, 96% of test takers received at least a 3 on the exam, according to the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE). The highest score offered on an AP exam is a 5, with a 3 considered passing.
“We do need guardrails around how many [tests] we administer,” Geiser said. “Tying the test to courses we teach helps to define which tests we give. It is difficult for us to absorb the unpredictable number of additional tests that could be requested from families who self-study.”
Masozera added that without the space or the predictability, the school is caught between what is being asked for and what might be practical.
“I understand to a degree what the school [district] is doing because there are 40 AP classes and 40 AP exams, and they can’t really do everything, so there is the question: Where do we draw the line?” he said.
Last year, 33 students took the AP Physics 1 exam, according to data from DESE, including Masozera. The exam is often taken by freshmen who elect to take honors-level physics and self-study for the test, he said. Eighteen students took the AP Physics C: Mechanics exam and 13 took the AP Physics C: Electricity & Magnetism exam, DESE reported.
Additional exams that students took that will no longer be offered this year are AP Italian, AP German, AP Human Geography, and AP U.S. Government and Politics.
BHS offers a college-prep and honors-level physics course, as well as AP Physics 2, which will be an exam still offered to students. For students who are interested in the subject, self-study exams can be a way to independently deepen their own knowledge, while also preparing for college and even getting credit.
“Without any other school classes to take, I turned to the self-study AP tests so that I could further strengthen my own knowledge and pursue my own interest in physics,” said Albert Ying, one of the captains of the physics club. “Having these tests is important to the learning of students and the continuation of their knowledge in physics.”
Student leaders in the high school’s physics club sent out a questionnaire to students at the beginning of this year to gauge interest in registering for the self-study exams. The form garnered 105 responses, many who said they wanted to take at least one of the self-study exams. While the form doesn’t translate into guaranteed sign-ups, students told The Voice they saw it as a sign their classmates have a clear interest in having the option.
“I think as of right now, there’s been a lot of frustration, both among parents and students,” Ying said.
The deadline to register for AP exams is Nov. 13, though many schools close requests for outside students to take exams on Nov. 1. Now, some students who were planning on taking a self study exam at BHS are scrambling to find a placement elsewhere — and fear facing late fees.
The typical cost per AP exam is $99. However, any exam requested after Nov. 13 will incur an additional $40 fee per exam. Host schools may also impose additional fees.
“It’s almost impossible for us to find schools,” said Kushal Upadhyay, adding the physics club has been doing outreach to schools within a 45-minute radius of BHS to try and find placements for students looking to take a physics exam.
Ying added that the issue isn’t simple, and may not be possible to resolve this year, but that students are hopeful the school will reconsider its stance.
“I’m sure they have their reasons that we don’t fully understand for doing this, but again, it is frustrating for us and other students,” he said.
